Isaac Howard, a forward for Michigan State and a prospect of the Tampa Bay Lightning, has officially won the 2025 Hobey Baker Award — the top individual honor in college hockey. After an incredible season, Howard stood out among top-tier talent and claimed the title over fellow finalists Zeev Buium of the University of Denver and Ryan Leonard from Boston College. His performance was not just impressive — it was historic for his program. But despite this success, his future with the Lightning remains uncertain.
A Season to Remember for Howard
Isaac Howard had one of the most dominant seasons in college hockey this year. After transferring to Michigan State last season, the junior forward took his game to a new level. He scored 52 points, ranking fifth in the nation, and his 26 goals were the third-highest total across the NCAA.
Howard wasn’t just a top scorer — he was the offensive leader for Michigan State, finishing 21 points ahead of any other teammate. His speed, creativity, and consistent ability to find the net made him a constant threat. It’s clear that he wasn’t just playing well — he was carrying the team on his back. Winning the Hobey Baker was a fitting reward for a season that had everything.
Drafted, But Not Signed: What Happened with Tampa Bay?
Howard was drafted 31st overall in the 2022 NHL Draft by the Tampa Bay Lightning and was expected to move to the pro level after this season. But surprisingly, the two sides couldn’t come to an agreement.
Howard spoke about the failed negotiations on the Spittin Chiclets podcast, saying, “I guess we didn’t see eye to eye the same way I thought we would.” He also emphasized that he wasn’t expecting to jump straight into the NHL lineup, but was open to starting in the AHL with the Syracuse Crunch. Despite this, the Lightning didn’t move forward with signing him.
It’s possible Tampa Bay, now focused on the playoffs, didn’t feel the timing was right to bring in a rookie — even one as talented as Howard. The recent additions of Yanni Gourde and Oliver Bjorkstrand likely reduced his chances of making the roster this year.
Returning to Michigan State for One More Year
Instead of turning pro, Howard will return to college for his senior year at Michigan State. It’s not just a second chance to win another Hobey Baker — it’s a chance to chase a national title and finish what he started. His decision to return may have come from frustration, but he’s embracing it as a new opportunity.
This return gives Michigan State fans one more year to watch a superstar play, and it sets up Howard to further cement his name in MSU’s history.
Could He Become a Free Agent?
Howard’s NHL rights are held by Tampa Bay until August 15, 2026. If he doesn’t sign before then, he can become an unrestricted free agent and sign with any NHL team. That opens the door for him to become one of the most sought-after college players on the market next summer.
If his relationship with Tampa Bay is indeed strained, there’s a real possibility he could walk away. And for a team like the Lightning — whose prospect pool isn’t overflowing with elite talent — losing a player like Howard for nothing would be a huge blow.
What’s Next for Isaac Howard?
In the short term, Howard is focused on next season with Michigan State. He’ll look to lead the team deeper into the NCAA tournament and defend his Hobey Baker title. But off the ice, the NHL world will be watching closely to see if Tampa Bay makes a move to bring him into the fold — or if they let one of the top college players walk.
Howard, now 22, is already a proven scorer with high-level skill and leadership. Whether it’s with the Lightning or another team in the future, his NHL career seems like a matter of when, not if.
Isaac Howard’s Hobey Baker win marks the peak of a brilliant college hockey season, but it also brings attention to the uncertainty surrounding his pro future. Despite being one of the most electric players in college hockey, Howard and the Tampa Bay Lightning couldn’t reach a deal, leading him to return to Michigan State.
As he sets his sights on another run for college hockey’s top prize and a national title, NHL teams will continue to monitor his situation closely. If things remain unresolved with Tampa Bay, Howard could become a major free agent target in 2026. Until then, fans can look forward to another thrilling season from one of college hockey’s biggest stars.
